Monday, April 15, 2024

What if Argentina World Cup 1946

South American Champion 1946

Please also see my All-Time World Cup Team Index.

La Máquina, which translates to "The Machine" in English, is a term commonly used to refer to the legendary football team of Club Atlético River Plate.   They played during the 1940s and is renowned for its remarkable attacking prowess and technical excellence. The core of the team was composed of five exceptional players: Ángel Labruna, José Manuel Moreno, Adolfo Pedernera, Félix Loustau, and Juan Carlos Muñoz. These players formed a formidable attacking unit that dominated Argentine football during their time together.  Sometimes, Alfredo Di Stefano, Nestor Rossi and goalkeeper Amadeo Carrizo were considered a part of the team.  Unfortunately, the prime years of La Máquina coincided with the outbreak of World War II, leading to the cancellation of the World Cup Finals in both 1942 and 1946. The global conflict disrupted international sports events, including the prestigious tournament. Consequently, the players from this team were unable to showcase their talents on the world stage during this period.  So, what if a World Cup Finals were held in 1946 with the participation of Argentina?

I opted to construct an alternative 1946 team for Argentina rather than focusing on 1942 for several reasons. Firstly, Argentina's impressive feat of clinching three consecutive South American Championships from 1945 to 1947 underscored the prowess of their national team during this period, making it a compelling foundation for a hypothetical 1946 World Cup scenario. José Manuel Moreno also did not play in the 1946 South America Championship making this team more interesting than just copying the actual Argentine team in 1946.  Furthermore, the emergence of young talents like Alfredo Di Stefano and Nestor Rossi by 1946 offers exciting possibilities for reshaping the team composition, as they were not part of the picture in 1942.

While considering a 1950 team could have been an option due to Argentina's non-participation in that World Cup Finals, the decline of Moreno by that time diminishes the star quality of that team compared to the vibrancy and promise embodied by the players in 1946.

 Boye, Mendes, Di Stefano, Moreno and Lustau

The Other Contenders
I am not going to predict the outcome of the 1946 World Cup Finals.  Instead, I looked into some of the major teams during this period.  England, Italy, Brazil, Hungary and perhaps Sweden alongside Argentina were probably the best teams in 1946.  Argentina probably would be the favorite because they had depth on the team.  Norberto Méndez, René Pontoni and Rinaldo Martino were as good as the players from La Maquina. 

Austria: By 1946, a significant portion of the renowned Wunderteam were gone, but Franz Binder remained a stalwart figure for Austria, notably representing the nation in that year. He played against Czechoslovakia a team that featured Josef Bican in 1946. Bican switched to represent Czechoslovakia from 1938 to 1949. Ernst Ocwirk already made his Austria national team debut in 1945 before appearing at the 1948 Olympic Games in London. Walter Zemen and Ernst Stojaspal also had earned their first senior cap by then, but Ernst Happel was not even 21 years old in 1946. Karl Decker was also an important player for them in this period.

Brazil: By the time the 1950 World Cup Finals arrived, Brazil had assembled a team that would go down in history as one of their finest. Prior to that, they were recognized as the team that had relinquished the South America Championship title to Argentina in both 1945 and 1946. Brazil emerged triumphant in 1949, ending a 27-year drought by clinching their first championship. It's worth noting that Argentina chose to boycott that particular tournament.  In 1946, however, Brazil would have feature a team of Zizinho, Leonidas, Ademir de Menezes, Jair, Moacir Barbosa, Tesourinha, Danilo Alvim and Domingos da Guia.  Domingos da Guia was named the Player of the Tournament in the 1945 South American Championship.  Meanwhile, Leonidas would be almost 33 years at the time of the 1946 World Cup Finals.  During the 1946 South American Championship, he suffered a muscle strain, which limited his participation to only one game.  He was a key player as Brazil beat Argentina in the1945 Copa Roca.  The Copa Roca tournament was a month before the 1946 South America Championship and about 6 months before the imaginary 1946 World Cup Finals.

Czechoslovakia: Josef Bican represented Czechoslovakia 15 times scoring 15 goals. Meanwhile, László Kubala also appeared in six games and scored four goals for Czechoslovakia between 1946 and 1947, but he only played alongside Josef Bican twice. One of the matches was against Austria in October 1946.  Their next game was against Poland in August 1947, where they scored two goals each for a 6-3 victory.  

England: England and the other Home Nations rejoined FIFA in 1947, marking their return to international football. However, it is plausible to speculate that without the war, their return could have occurred earlier. The 1946-1947 season marked the official return of the English league after the war, but the British Victory Home Championship took place the season before. The matches were not formally recognized as full internationals, they were referred to as Victory Internationals. It is worth noting that Scotland emerged as the victor in this championship. The following year, England went on to win the 1946-1947 Home International Championship. Frank Swift, Franklin Neil, Bill Wright, Tommy Lawton, Stanley Matthew, Wilf Mannion, Raich Carter, Tom Finney and Stan Mortensen were some of the top English players in 1946. Jack Rowley perhaps might make the team.
England vs Argentina 1951
France: Larbi Ben Barek was a big star in France whole playing for Stade Francais in 1946.  Julien Darui was one the best goalkeepers in the 1940's.  Roger Marche was an emerging player who would earn his first cap in 1947. 

Hungary: Ferenc Deak rather than Ferenc Puskas was the top player in Hungary.  In the 1945-1946 season, he netted 66 goals. It remained a world record for the number of goals scored in a single season.  The same season, Puskas scored 36 goals in 34 games.  The other top players in that era included Ferenc Szusza and Ferenc Rudas. József Bozsik was 20 years old in 1946.  He had not made his national team debut. István Nyers had a brief spell playing in Czechoslovakia in 1946, but he was in the national team players' pool in 1946.  Sándor Szűcs was still alive in 1946. György Sárosi was still an active player, but he was 33 years in 1946.  He no longer played for Hungary.  Gyula Zsengellér was Europe's top goalscorer in 1945.  His last cap was in 1947. While playing with ŠK Slovan Bratislava, László Kubala appeared in six games and scored four goals for Czechoslovakia between 1946 and 1947. After returning to Budapest in 1948, he played three games for Hungary but failed to score.  He remained a possible player for Hungary. I also created a 1950 World Cup team for Hungary. 

Italy: Valentino Mazzola served as the captain and iconic figure of the renowned "Grande Torino" team, widely acknowledged as one of the strongest in the world during the latter half of the 1940s. In the 1946-1947 season, Mazzola concluded the season as the league's top scorer, netting an impressive 29 goals. Notably, on April 20, 1946, Mazzola etched his name in Italian football history by scoring the fastest hat-trick ever recorded, achieving this remarkable feat with three goals in just three minutes against Vicenza.  This exceptional team formed the core of the Italian national team during that period. Silvio Piola served as the national side's captain from 1940 until 1947.  Giampiero Boniperti, Amedeo Biavati, Virgilio Maroso Virgilio Maroso, Carlo Parola and Pietro Rava were also members of the national team.  Gino Capello was still uncapped in 1946. Giuseppe Meazza was still an active player but had passed his prime.

Scotland: Liked England, Scotland returned to FIFA in 1947.  They won the 1945–46 British Victory Home Championship. They also played two international matches in 1946.  They drew with Belgium 2-2 in January 1946 and beat Switzerland 3-1 in May.  They were counted by the Scottish Football Association as official matches.  Billy Liddell of Liverpool FC was an active player.

Spain:  Spain was unable to participate in any competitive matches between the 1934 World Cup and the 1950 World Cup qualifiers due to the disruptions caused by the Spanish Civil War and World War II. They finished fourth in the 1950 World Cup Finals.  In 1946, they only played a single friendly match.  Telmo Zarra was in his prime.  The other top players included Agustín Gaínza, Ignacio Eizaguirre and César Rodríguez.  Both Estanislau Basora and Luis Molowny joined Barcelona and Real Madrid respectively in 1946.  

Sweden: The "Gre-No-Li" helped Sweden to win the 1948 Olympic Gold Medal.  It was the first major football tournament since the end of the War.  Six Swedish players turned professional after the Olympics. In the 1950's, the Swedish football association did not allow any professional footballers to play for the national team. Consequently, Sweden only fielded amateur players during the World Cup Finals in 1950.  Despite of that, Sweden managed to finish third and the best European team in the tournament.  Besides the "Gre-No-Li", Sweden could also feature Henry Carlsson, Erik Nilsson and the other two Nordahl brothers in this 1946 World Cup Finals.  Sune Andersson was uncapped at this point.  I also did an alternative team for Sweden in the 1950 World Cup Finals.

Uruguay: Uruguay only finished 4th in the 1946 South American Championship.  Walter Gómez had not made a name with River Plate in 1946, but he played in that tournament alongside Roque Máspoli and Obdulio Varela. José María Medina was the overall top scorer of the tournament. Juan Alberto Schiaffino made national debut in 1946 while Alcides Ghiggia was still an unknown player in Uruguay. Argentine-born Atilio García represented them in 1945, but not in 1946. Roberto Porta also ended his national team career, but Schubert Gambetta and Eusebio Tejera were available. 

West Germany: They were banned from playing in FIFA matches until 1950, but this World Cup Finals only happened if there was no war.  Fritz Walter had returned from the war by 1946. He played for Kaiserslautern.  Bert Trautmann who never played for West Germany had not started his football career.  

Yugoslavia: Stjepan Bobek, Rajko Mitić, Zlatko Čajkovski, Branko Stanković and Ivica Horvat were active national team players in 1946.  They won the silver medal in the 1948 Olympics.

Other top Players in the 1940's: Fernando Peyroteo scored 56 goals in the 1945-1946 season. It was his best output in a single season. There were also John Hansen (Denmark) and Sergio Livingston (Chile).  Arseni Erico just passed his prime.

Team
GK: Claudio Vacca (Boca Juniors)
Vacca began his career at Huracán and later joined Boca Juniors in 1938. Initially a substitute goalkeeper, he made his official debut in 1938 and became a regular starter in 1943. Vacca won six titles with Boca Juniors and also represented the Argentina national football team seven times. After leaving Boca Juniors in 1950, he played for Defensor Sporting in Uruguay before retiring in 1951. He won the South American Champion in 1946.


GK: Julio Cozzi (Club Atlético Platense)
Cozzi started his career in 1941 with Club Atlético Platense. He played for the club until 1949 when he joined Millonarios of Colombia where his teammates included Alfredo di Stéfano and Adolfo Pedernera. He returned to Platense in 1955, he went on to play for Independiente between 1956 and 1959 and then Banfield of the Argentine 2nd division. He played 6 times for Argentina winning the South American Champion in 1947.

Julio Cozzi
RCB: Carlos Sosa (Boca Juniors)
Carlos Sosa started his career with Atlanta in 1939.  He joined Boca Juniors in the 1941, where he established as one of the best defenders of his generation.  He won two Argentine Primera División. He went to play in France in 1952.  He played for Racing Paris and Red Stars in Paris.  With Argentina, he was capped 12 times between 1942 and 1946. He won two Copa Americas(1945 and 1946). he was considered one of  Argentina's greatest ever defenders.

RCB: Norberto Yacon (River Plate)
Noberto Yacon was a member of River Plate's "La Máquina" in 1940's. He made his debut in 1938. He remained with the club until 1953, when he moved to play in Mexico for America.  He also played in Canada. The highlight of his career with Argentina was the South American Championship 1947 in which La Selección won the tournament undefeated. He earned 15 caps between 1942 and 1951.

CB: Juan Carlos Fonda (Platense)
Juan Carlos Fonda, born on October 5, 1919, in Vedia, Buenos Aires, began his professional career at Boca Juniors in 1941. After playing for Vélez, Boca (briefly), and Platense, he eventually joined Racing Club in 1946. Racing Club signed him due to his consistent performances at Vicente López's team.  He played 10 times for Argentina winning the 1946 South American Championship.

LCB: José Marante (Boca Juniors)
Marante began his career at Boca Juniors in 1934. He was Domingos da Guía's backup. In 1938, Marante played 25 games alongside Menéndez and Valussi. During that time, Claudio Vacca joined Boca Juniors, forming a notable trio. In 1939, Marante was loaned to Ferro Carril Oeste, but returned to Boca Juniors in 1940, winning consecutive championships in 1943 and 1944.  he won two South American championship in 1946 and 1947.
Norberto Yacon against England
LCB: Eduardo Rodríguez (River Plate)
Rodríguez made his debut with Estudiantes de La Plata in 1939 and became a regular player in the early 1940s. He joined River Plate in 1945, winning championships in 1945 and 1947. He later moved to Colombia during the El Dorado period. Rodríguez had three appearances and a goal for the national team between 1943 and 1946. He was a part of the team that won the 1946 South American Championship.

LCB: Juan Carlos Sobrero (Newell's Old Boys)
Sobrero started his football career with Newell's Old Boys in 1939. He represented Argentina in the 1946 and 1947 Copa América helping Argentina win the title. He also participated in the 1947 Copa América.  In 1949, he joined Racing Club de Avellaneda and won the Argentine league title. Sobrero retired in 1950, concluding his career with Newell's Old Boys. Throughout his career, he played 244 matches in the Argentine league and scored two goals.

DM: Nestor Rossi (River Plate)
Nestor Rossi is one of Argentina's greatest defensive midfielders.  Nicknamed "Pipo", he started his career at River Plate, playing from 1945 to 1949, and then again from 1955 to 1958, winning a total of 5 Argentine leagues. He played with La Maquina, but at the end of their peak.  he also played in Colombia. He also won 6 more with Millonarios in Colombia. He played in the 1958 World Cup Finals and was a part of their 1957 Copa America winning team.
Nestor Rossi 
CM: Natalio Pescia (Boca Juniors)
Pescia was part of one of the most remembered midfield lines in the history of Boca Juniors, along with Carlos Sosa and Ernesto Lazzatti between 1943 and 1947 when Boca Juniros won the 1943 and 1944 domestic leagues, apart from one Copa Ibarguren, one Copa de Competencia Británica and two Copa Escobar-Gerona. At the international level, he received his first callus in 1945, but made his debut in 1946. He was capped 12 times 

LB/LM: Jose Ramos  (River Plate)
Born in 1918, Jose Ramos started with Lanus, where he played a single season in 1939.  He was also a member of River Plate's "La Máquina" in 1940's. He played left back and midfield.  He retired in 1952.  At the international level, he was capped 11 times between 1942 and 1946.  He was a key midfielder as Argentina won Copa America in 1946.

CM: León Strembel (Racing Club)
Strembel began his career with Club Atlético Lanús in 1939. He played for the club until 1944, before joining Racing Club de Avellaneda from 1945 to 1946. He also played for Argentina appearing in the South American Championship 1946. In 1947 he joined Club Atlético Atlanta. Strembel returned to Lanús for the following season where he played until his retirement in 1956.

IR: José Manuel Moreno (Espana, Mexico)
José Manuel Moreno was the star of  "La Máquina" of River Plate in the 1940's.  Some older fans in Argentina considered him better than Diego Maradona and Alfredo Di Stefano. He never played in the World Cup Finals due to the World War II, but won the South American Championships of 1941, 1942 and 1947. He also played club football in Mexico and Colombia.  He was the first footballer ever to have won first division league titles in four countries 
José Manuel Moreno 
IR: Vicente De la Mata (Independiente)
Vicente De la Mata emerged from the youth team of Central Córdoba in 1936, he was soon signed by Independiente where he spent 14 seasons, scoring 151 goals in 362 games for the club. He played alongside Antonio Sastre and Arsenio Erico.  Capped 13 times between 1937 and 1946, scoring six goals. He won Copa América on three occasions. In 1937 he scored both goals in the 2–0 win over Brazil in the final. 

IR: Norberto Méndez (Racing Club)
Norberto Méndez started his playing career with Huracán in 1941. In 1947 he moved to Racing Club where he helped the club become tricampeones (triple champions) by winning the Primera Division Argentina titles of 1949, 1950 and 1951. He played 33 games for Argentina and won 3 Copa América titles. He is perhaps most famous for being the all-time top scorer in the history of the Copa América with 17 goals.

IL/FW: Ángel Labruna (River Plate)
Ángel Labruna is the second top scorer of the Argentine First Division with 293 goals. He was also part of River Plate's La Máquina (The Machine), and he was considered one of the best South-American footballers of his generation.  He played 37 matches for Argentina, scoring 17 goals. He also won two South American Championships (1946 and 1955) and as a nearly 40-year-old he played in the final phase of 1958 World Cup held in Sweden.
Ángel Labruna 
IL: Rinaldo Martino (San Lorenzo)
Rinaldo Martino was signed by San Lorenzo in 1941 at the age of 19 from Belgrano de Rosario.  In 1949 Martino joined Juventus in Italy, helping them to record their first championship since the 1930s. He retuned to South America.  He played with Nacional in Uruguay, Boca Juniors and C.A. Cerro. He earned over 20 caps for Argentina before moving to play in Italy, where he earned a single cap for Italy.

RW: Mario Boye  (Boca Juniors)  
"El Atómico (The Atomic One)" Mario Boye made his debut with Boca Juniors in 1941. With Boca he won the 1943 and 1944 Argentine leagues, and was the league's top-scorer in 1946 with 24 goals.  He also played for Genoa in Italy where he became "Il Matadore" (The Killer), but returned to Argentina four seasons later.  He played for Racing and Huracán. He earned 17 caps winning 3 straight Copa Americas.
Mario Boye
LW:  Félix Loustau (River Plate)
Félix Loustau was a member of River Plate's "La Máquina. He won 8 national titles during his time at the club. He is considered to be one of Argentina's greatest wingers. His international career was very limited because of the war. Nevertheless, he played 28 times for Argentina scoring ten goals between 1942 and 1958.  He won three straight Copa America in 1945, 1946, and 1947 with Argentina.

CF/SS: Adolfo Pedernera (River Plate)
Adolfo Pedernera was a member of "La Máquina".  He is still considered by many to be one of the greatest Argentine players of all-time. He was elected the 12th best South american footballer of the 20th century in a poll by the IFFHS in 2000. He moved to Atlanta in 1947 and Millonarios in Colombia.  Because of the Second World War, he did not play many games for Argentina. He still won the Copa America 1941 and 1945.

CF: Rene Pontoni (San Lorenzo)
Rene Pontoni started his career with Gimnasia y Esgrima de Santa Fe before joining Newell's Old Boys in 1940.  In 1944 Pontoni joined San Lorenzo where he helped the team to win the Primera División in 1946.  He also played for Independiente Santa Fe in Colombia and Portuguesa in Brazil. Pontoni made his debut for the Argentina  in 1942. He scored 19 goals in 19 games for his country, helping them to become South American champions in 1945, 1946 and 1947.

CF:   Alfredo Di Stefano (Huracán)
Alfredo Di Stefano was considered the best player in the world before the emerge of Pele and Maradona. He was one of the younger member of the great River Plate in the 1940's.  In 1949, he moved to play in Colombia before moving to Europe in 1953.  He won 5 straight European Cups with Real Madrid. He was credited in turning Real Madrid into a legendary club. His international career was limited to the fact that Argentina did not select overseas players.  He played for Argentina, Colombia and Spain.
Alfredo Di Stefano

Squad Explanation
-- Argentina experienced remarkable success in the South American Championship (Copa América) during the 1940s. They clinched the championship title in multiple editions of the tournament. Firstly, they emerged victorious in the 1941 edition. Then, they went on an impressive three-year winning streak, securing consecutive titles in 1945, 1946, and 1947. Of particular note was the 1946 edition, which coincided with the year of the World Cup. The final match between Argentina and Brazil in that tournament is often regarded as an unofficial World Cup final.
-- I based this team on the 1946 South American winning team, but I dropped five players. Julio Cozzi, Nestor Rossi, Alredo Di Stefano, Juan Manual Moreno and Noberto Yacon were added to the team.  I kept José Salomón out of the team because of a career ending injury he suffered in 1946.  He was Aregentina's most famous defender.
-- A total of five players participated in the three consecutive Copa Américas from 1945 to 1947. These players were Natalio Pescia, René Pontoni, Norberto Méndez, Mario Boyé, and Félix Loustau. Among them, only Félix Loustau had the distinction of being a starter in all three tournaments. 
-- The 1942 World Cup was originally awarded to Brazil, but the tournament was canceled in 1941 due to the escalation of the war and the logistical challenges it posed. Similarly, the 1946 World Cup, which was supposed to be held in Germany, was also canceled as the world was still recovering from the war's aftermath.
-- La Marquina won the Primera División in 1941, 1942, 1945 and 1947.  Boca Juniors took the 1943 and 1944 titles. The 1946 title went to San Lorenzo.  Both Boca Juniors and San Lorenzo also had one of their great teams in that era.
-- In 1944, Boca Juniors secured their second consecutive championship in the club's history. The decisive victory came in the final match against Racing, where Boca Juniors emerged triumphant with a resounding 3-0 scoreline. Due to incidents of hooliganism, the match took place at the River Plate stadium as the Bombonera, Boca Juniors' iconic home ground, was temporarily closed. Over the course of the season, Boca Juniors showcased their dominance, winning 19 out of 30 games played. They also recorded 8 draws and suffered only 3 losses. They also achieved an impressive unbeaten run of 26 consecutive matches, setting a new record in the professional era. This feat remained unmatched until Racing surpassed it in 1966, going undefeated for 39 matches. The lineup for the memorable clash against Racing is still revered as one of the greatest Boca Juniors' teams ever assembled. Vacca, Marante, Carlos Sosa, Pescia and Boyé made this team.
-- In 1946, San Lorenzo won the league title after 10 seasons. They scored a record of 90 goals in 30 games played while giving up only 37 goals. On the same year, San Lorenzo embarked on a remarkable tour of Spain and Portugal, which stands out as one of the most memorable moments in the club's history.  During their time in Europe, they played a total of 10 matches, including impressive victories over the Spanish national team by scores of 7-5 and 6-1. The Spanish crowd in the stadiums showered San Lorenzo with admiration, hailing them as "Son els millor del mon" (meaning "You are the best in the world" in Catalan). In Portugal, they thrashed Porto with a staggering 9-4 victory. Additionally, they showcased their prowess by defeating the Portugal national team with a convincing scoreline of 10-4. They faced their sole defeat during the tour at the hands of Real Madrid, who emerged triumphant with a 4-1 result.  As a result of the successful tour, player René Pontoni was offered a contract with Barcelona, but declined to leave Argentina (Barcelona then drafted River Plate's Alfredo Di Stéfano). Fellow player Rinaldo Martino did stay in European football and would later become a star with Juventus.
René Pontoni and Rinaldo Martino
-- La Máquina, under the guidance of coach Renato Cesarini, achieved remarkable success in the world of football. From 1941 to 1944, they secured four consecutive league championships, demonstrating their dominance in the sport. I took 7 players from their team in 1946.  Juan Manuel Moreno was playing in Mexico that year while Di Stefano was out on loan.
Goalkeepers
-- Argentina won three consecutive South American Championship titles between 1945 and 1947 with six different goalkeepers.  
-- In 1945, Argentina featured Fernando Bello and Hector Ricardo. Bello also helped Argentina to win the South America in 1937.  He had retired by 1946.  Ricardo started four of his team's six games in the 1945 edition, but he never played for Argentina again after 1945.  he would be 22 years in 1946.
-- The two goalkeepers on the 1946 team were Claudio Vacca and Gabriel Ogando. Vacca who played for Boca Juniors was the starter in the South America Championship. 
-- Julio Cozzi was the starting goalkeeper for the 1947 team.  His backup Obdulio Diano was a teammate of Claudio Vacca in Boca Juniors.  I did not know the goalkeeping situating with Boca Juniors between 1946 and 1947. 
Julio Cozzi 
-- Amadeo Carrizo made his first team debut in 1945, but he was mainly a backup for a few more years.  Sebastián Gualco had retired.
-- I decided to retain Claudio Vacca since he was the starter on the 1946 team.  For the second goalkeeper, I took Julio Cozzi.  He was probably the best goalkeeper on this list.  He would have been ranked higher in the All-Time list for Argentine goalkeeper if he played for a bigger club than Platense.  Later, he would make a name while playing for Millonarios in Colombia alongside Alfredo di Stéfano, Nestor Rossi and Adolfo Pedernera. Both Amadeo Carrizo and Alfredo di Stéfano considered him as the greatest goalkeepers of all-time.  
Defenders
-- José Salomón or Carlos Sosa were the greatest defenders of their generations.  I selected Carlos Sosa for my Argentina All-Time team while José Salomón is on my Argentina All-Time Team before 1978.
-- Jose Salomon was the captain and stalwart of the team.  In the 1946 Final, he broke his tibia and fibula from a tackle by Jair Rosa Pinto.  The injury would eventually end his career and fueled the football rivalry between Argentina and Brazil.  It was partially a reason why Argentina did not play in the 1948 South American Championship as well as the 1950 World Cup Finals, both held in Brazil.  He would never play for Argentina again.  What should we do with him for the 1946 World Cup Finals held in the Summer?
-- For my Great Britain 1970 World Cup team, I took an injured Denis Law to Mexico so that I could reunite him with the "United Trinity" in a World Cup Finals.  On the other hand, my Hungry 1950 World Cup team dropped Ferenc Rudas who suffered a career ending injury before the Finals.  Liked Solomon, he was one of the best defenders in the post-War period, but never recovered to his former self.  His situation was similar with Solomon.  However, Denis Law's career did continue after 1970, which still seemed realistic to include him.   Law, being a legendry player, added a level of prestige, glamour and excitement to that team. 
-- Argentina did not play any international match between the 1946 Final in February and the first match of the next South American Championship 21 months later.   For the 1947 South American Championship team, they added Nicolas Palma, Norberto Yácono, Juan Carlos Colman and Nestor Rossi (who also operated as a central defender would make his debut in December 1947). 
-- Norberto Yácono was brought back after a 4-year absence.  I checked his record.  He played regularly in 1946 and 1947 for River Plate.  There was no reason why not to select him earlier in 1946.  He was Argentina's best man-marker of his time.
-- For the rest of the defenders, I retained José Marante, Juan Carlos Fonda, Eduardo Rodríguez and Juan Carlos Sobrero from the 1946 South American Championship winning team.  Sobrero played many times for Argentina in 1946 and 1947.
Juan Carlos Fonda
-- Saúl Ongaro who was a Centre-half was playing for Estudiantes de La Plata in 1946.  He later joined Racing Club in 1947, winning two league titles in 1949 and 1950.  Nestor Rossi in a World Cup Finals alongside his River Plate teammates added a much more romance to the team.  Was it realistic? Rossi made his River Plate debut in June 1945.  He immediately became a starter.  Many considered him the best player for River Plate the following season in 1946, but if the World Cup Finals would have been held in June, the season would still be on Match Day 5 at the beginning of the World Cup Finals.  Logically, it was still premature to select him in June 1946 when his first cap came in December 1947, but I decided to take him.
-- Víctor Valussi of Boca Juniors was also a player of note in the 1940's, but he was 34 years old in 1946 and his last cap was in 1942.  Ricardo Vaghi never played for Argentina.  He was out of question.  I also did not consider Armando Renganeschi who was born in Argentina but played club football in Brazil.
Midfielders/Wingers
-- I did not want to change much from Argentina's South America Championship winning team. So, I retained Natalio Pescia, José Ramos, León Strembel.  Carlos Sosa, Norberto Yácono and Nestor Rossi could also be considered to be midfielders.  Both Carlos Sosa and Yacono were right half-back.  Rossi would be a centrehalf.
-- Natalio Pescia was one of the five players who won three South American Championship 3 times in a row.   He was a part of the famous midfield for Boca Juniors that won two league titles in 1943 and 1944.   This midfield was made up of his teammates Carlos Sosa and Ernesto Lazzatti. Lazzatti won the South American Championship in 1937.
-- Jose Ramos and Norberto Yácono formed the midfield for La Maquina.  Ramos was a left midfielder while Yacono played on the right.  He was either the right midfielder or the fullback.  Bruno Rodolfi played in the middle for them, but he was at the end of his career by 1946.  His last cap came in 1943.  So, I selected Rossi over him.  
-- In 1946, Leon Strembel was playing for Racing Club.  He left in 1947 before the club won three straight league titles between 1949 and 1951.
-- Inside-Right Antonio Sastre was also a big star in South America, but by 1946, he had passed his prime. So, I kept Norberto Mendez and Vicente De la Mata.  At Independiente, Vincente De La Mata formed a famous line with Antonio Sastre and Arsenio Erico.  He was also the hero of the 1937 South American Championship Final.  Mendez was a key player in the actual 1946 tournament.  He was Argentina's top scorer for the tournaments in 1945, 1946 and 1947.
Norberto Méndez
-- José Manuel Moreno was one of the five forwards of La Maquina, but his role was to track back and covered the whole right side. He nominally played as an inside right or left which is a position known as an attacking midfielder today. He was a total footballer ahead of his time.
-- In 1944, due to contractual issues with River Plate, Jose Manuel Moreno left for Mexico and join Club España. During his time there, he formed a formidable partnership with Isidro Lángara, and won the 1946 championship. Due to his decision to move to Mexico, Moreno was unable to participate in both the 1945 and 1946 South American Championships.  On July 28, 1946, at the age of 27, Moreno made his highly anticipated return to River Plate.  The 1946 World Cup Finals would have played a month earlier in June. In real life, he played in the 1947 South American Championship and was voted as the best player of the tournament.  So, he was still a top player in South America.
-- For inside-left, I took Rinaldo Martino.  He helped San Lorenzo to win the league that year.  And then, I took Ángel Labruna.
-- Bartholomew Colombo was a part of San Lorenzo that won the league that year.  Angel Perucca went to both 1945 and 1947 South American Championship.  Ernesto Gutiérrez was only 18 years old in 1946.   I decided not to alter the team too much.  So, I left them off the team.
-- The right-wing position on the 1946 was occupied by Mario Boyé who was a star with Boca Juniors and Juan Carlos Salvini.  Juan Carlos Muñoz of River Plate went to the 1945 South American Championship but was not on the 1946 team. He was famous due to playing for La Maquina. I decided to take Boye only.
-- On the left, I first took Félix Loustau. Manuel Pelegrina might be a more famous left winger than Ezra Sued, but he was not on the 1946 team.  I also only took Loustau.
Forwards
-- The Inside Right and left positions were actually considered to be forwards, but I put them on the midfielders/wingers section.
-- Alfredo Di Stéfano was a similar player as Moreno, but he played as a central forward in 1946.  He only played a single game for River Plate for the 1945 season before going on loan to Club Atlético Huracán in 1946. In the 1946 season, he immediately made an impact, but the World Cup Finals would be held in June.  Liked Rossi would Di Stefano be ready for the World Cup Finals?  It was noteworthy that Guillermo Stábile was the coach for both Huracan and the Argentine national team at the same time.  So, he did know about Di Stefano very well by June. 1946. Furthermore, one of main points of this blog team was to incorporate Di Stefano onto the team. 
-- René Pontoni was one of the players who won three straight South American Championship. That season, he helped San Lorenzo to win the league title. Other top central forwards in their period included Jaime Sarlanga.  Herminio Masantonio had retired.  
-- Adolfo Pedernera would also withdraw to midfield, confounding the central defenders who were supposed to mark him, and opening spaces for the wingers.
Adolfo Pedernera 

Formation
I did not think Alfredo Di Stefano was ready to start, but I gambled on Nestor Rossi. Because of Juan Manuel Moreno, Norberto Mendez had to sit on the bench.  Rinaldo Martino could also start as the inside left, 




Posted by at No comments:
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)